Stay up to date with News from NaviStone®

26 Jan

Direct Mail Marketing vs. Online: Which Is Most Effective?

Author: Megan Rainey

Comments 0

Direct Mail

Direct Mail or Digital

Direct mail marketing and digital marketing are two of the most popular marketing tactics. But which marketing channels are most effective? The short answer is that traditional direct mail marketing is more effective than online marketing.

Despite technology’s advancements, traditional marketing still reigns supreme among marketers. Direct mail and print ads have been around for years to promote products and create brand awareness. Traditional marketing remains at the forefront of marketing strategies everywhere, with good returns and a history of success.

Digital marketing tactics are newer to the game, but they bring considerable benefits. Internet marketing takes significant time and effort, and strategies must promote services and products with a compelling message to maintain revenue or increase sales.

Reaching your target audience or getting conversions is possible in many ways. No matter what your business needs, you can achieve your marketing goals with either. However, a combination of both traditional marketing and digital campaigns can also help reach potential consumers.

Read on to explore the differences between each marketing strategy and find out for yourself which campaign tactics are best to market your business.

Direct Mail Marketing vs. Online: Which is Most Effective?

Direct mail marketing and digital marketing are two of the most popular marketing tactics. But which marketing channels are most effective? The short answer is that traditional direct mail marketing is more effective than online marketing.

Despite technology’s advancements, traditional marketing still reigns supreme among marketers. Direct mail and print ads have been around for years to promote products and create brand awareness. Traditional marketing remains at the forefront of marketing strategies everywhere, with good returns and a history of success.

Digital marketing tactics are newer to the game, but they bring considerable benefits. Internet marketing takes significant time and effort, and strategies must promote services and products with a compelling message to maintain revenue or increase sales.

Reaching your target audience or getting conversions is possible in many ways. No matter what your business needs, you can achieve your marketing goals with either. However, a combination of both traditional marketing and digital campaigns can also help reach potential consumers.

Read on to explore the differences between each marketing strategy and find out for yourself which campaign tactics are best to market your business.

Does Direct Mail Beat Digital Marketing?

Direct mail is a worthy competitor against digital marketing. The traditional marketing strategy offers some compelling points in proving its effectiveness. With its timeless success, better response rates, strong return on investment, and trustworthy delivery method, companies can quickly see how direct mail beats digital marketing.

You don’t have to use the most modern marketing techniques. Traditional marketing is still going strong after decades. Familiarity and exclusive discounts are something people look forward to daily.

Every Smart Brand Is (Still) Doing Direct Mail

The most successful brands haven’t stopped doing direct mail campaigns just because we live in a digital world. The most innovative company still sends direct mailers and ads to consumers.

One way a company can create a memorable customer experience is by providing a tangible piece of mail. This reminder helps with conversion by funneling leads to digital channels and helps customers make purchase decisions. Additionally, by marketing with a physical piece featuring personalization and eye-catching designs, your campaign will be more likely to attract consumers and create brand awareness.

Advanced tools for direct mail retargeting make it easier to implement successful direct mail marketing in your business’s operation. Companies can leverage their website browsing data to identify prospects and deliver personalized and timely direct mail to their home.

Direct Mail Response Rates Are Better Than Digital

Your campaign message should spur potential customers to take action. Direct mail has consistently had better response rates than digital campaigns. Businesses can utilize direct mail to get sales after first drawing their interest. Digital programs are consistently effective at driving site traffic, top of funnel activity. Direct mail programs are consistently effective at driving conversions, bottom of funnel activity.

House lists boast a more than five-percent response rate. This success is hard to match with an online ad or email campaign, even when a campaign has a specific target audience. Email marketing has a 0.6% response rate compared to the nearly three-percent response rate from prospective customers receiving direct mail.

Due to the significant difference in response rates, it’s clear that a direct mail campaign can be especially beneficial in promoting your brand and services.

Direct Mail Is No Slouch When It Comes to ROI

While direct mail response rates provide marketers with that high level indicator of performance, ROI is a critical KPI for normalizing performance across marketing programs that have different costs. Statistics prove that print, radio, and direct mail campaigns are among the most effective advertising methods to gain returns. The average ROI for direct marketing is nearly 30%.

The personalized aspect of direct marketing, a tangible piece of advertising, and improved brand recall contribute to this growth.

When implementing a memorable campaign, traditional marketing tactics allow consumers to experience something new. Spreading your company message with impactful packaging or personalization can significantly increase customers’ interest.

People Trust Direct Mail More Than Digital

Print advertising and direct mail have been popular for years. Due to its reputation and longevity as a well-known, way to receive offers and find businesses, people trust direct mail more than a digital marketing campaign. 57% of consumers say “a postcard makes them feel valued and creates an authentic relationship. “Many people look forward to receiving mail.

The trustworthiness of a traditional marketing tactic contributes to its success. Catalogs, flyers, and postcards do well at influencing a company’s audience to buy something online.

Does Digital Marketing Beat Direct Mail?

Since its first arrival on the scene, digital marketing, offering some significant benefits regarding timeliness, ROI, and ad costs, has grown quickly to become a leading marketing tactic.

Today, brands utilize content across various platforms.

Online advertising gives its print counterpart a modern update for an affordable price. The returns are extensive no matter the utilized platforms. Thanks to more digital channels, reaching your target audience is also easier and faster than before.

There are many ways to get exposure online, from social media to email. From utilizing different channels to create brand awareness to targeting a specific audience for increased sales, digital marketing is known to offer a tremendous amount of flexibility.

Target audiences have grown with their favorite companies. Technology makes it easier for potential customers to find the necessary information on any brand. Compared to traditional marketing, digital options also improve audience interaction.

Direct Mail vs. Digital Marketing: What Should You Use?

A significant debate for many businesses is whether they should use traditional marketing or digital marketing. Luckily, you don’t have to choose between the two. Both techniques are effective in their own ways.

Viewing these marketing strategies as complementary will help you implement them together. Considering they offer different advantages, there’s no reason to use just one. Your business can use both to help targeted ads reach their selected demographic.

Omnichannel marketing gives you the ultimate marketing assistance. This combined marketing strategy is a comprehensive solution to the division between market subcategories.

Omnichannel Marketing: Direct Mail and Digital Marketing Working Together

Digital marketing and traditional marketing (direct mail strategies) combine physical or tangible and digital or non-tangible ads. Businesses that use both together can achieve larger returns and responses than those that utilize one. Omnichannel marketing gives you the flexibility your strategy needs.

The best strategy includes multiple tactics across several channels. Using an online and direct mail solution means you can offer customers the best experience through their channels of choice and maintain brand consistency. And, bridging the gap between the two by using online intent data to inform a direct mail solution, is even better.

A company utilizing an email to promote a product can create a decent return. Combining that outreach with a traditional channel is what sweetens the deal. 

Walking a Mile in Nisolo's Shoes